Marketplace Fraud Tactics

Spotlight Keywords:
Sellers
Buyers
Fraud
Platforms
Trust
Online Crime
Impersonation
Payments
Risk

We live in a time when we can search for anything we need, and within a day or so (sometimes even sooner) it’s at our front door. Online marketplaces like Amazon, Walmart and Alibaba fuel this engine—processing millions of orders every single day. But how many of those orders are legitimate, and how many are scams?

According to research, merchants were estimated to have lost $38 billion to online payment fraud in 2023. The same research forecasts this number will soar to $362 billion globally by 2028.

With new technology, scams are becoming more sophisticated. And with the launch of more shopping platforms (e.g. TikTok Shop), scammers are finding new avenues to reach their next victims. Some pose as genuine sellers to scam buyers, and others pose as genuine buyers to scam sellers. It’s a two-pronged problem.

As an online shopping platform that wants to protect its users from fraud, how can you spot a scammer? And what are some of the common scams to look out for?

Online marketplace scams

Counterfeit Goods

Research from Ofcom showed that counterfeit goods are the second most common type of online scam in the UK (just behind impersonation fraud).

Counterfeit goods are often associated with expensive designer items. Scammers lie to buyers—selling them “genuine designer items” at designer prices, only for them to receive bad quality knock-offs that don’t hold any brand value.

In November 2023, Homeland Security and the New York Police Department uncovered over $1 billion of fake designer goods in what federal authorities called “the largest seizure of counterfeit goods in U.S history”, saving thousands of consumers from fraudulent sales.

But it doesn’t end with fake Rolexes and knock-off Chanel bags. Counterfeit cosmetics are becoming a serious concern on TikTok’s shopping platform. Samples retrieved by the UK’s Police Intellectual Property Crime Unit flagged toxic levels of arsenic, mercury and lead. And in LA, U.S. Customs and Border Protection seized nearly $400K worth of fake Apple products, resembling iPods and Apple Watches.

How to Spot a Scam | 5 Common Online Marketplace Scams

Fake product reviews

Fake reviews are misleading and deceptive.

The first online reviews started appearing around the late 1990s. They were designed to add an extra layer of protection for consumers in this new, unchartered world of online shopping.

And today, they still work! Genuine reviews are, without a doubt, one the greatest markers of trust for buyers and sellers. It’s why 90% of people read online reviews before making a purchase.

Scam artists know this, and consequently create fake reviews to appear more trustworthy. They pay fraudulent review rings to prop up their products and convince genuine buyers that their order will be honored and their money is safe. Unfortunately, they soon find out this isn’t the case.

Fake product listings

Fake product listings are exactly what they sound like. The listing doesn't match the product the buyer receives.

In some cases, the photograph looks nothing like the product. It’s often poor quality or it’s damaged.

In other cases, buyers receive something that’s completely different from what they ordered. What was supposed to be an iPad, is actually a heavy book in an iPad box.

Sometimes, scammers are a lot more subtle. They make misleading claims in the product description—promising extra long battery life, or a shampoo that’s “clinically proven” to restore your hairline to its original glory. Needless to say, the product doesn’t deliver on its claims.

But in most instances, customers buy a product from a fake listing and receive nothing in return.

Account takeovers

To combat fraud, many platforms now require ID verification from all of their users.

However, scammers have found ways around this. Most notably, by orchestrating account takeovers (otherwise known as “account hacking”). This is where fraudsters take ownership of buyer (or seller) accounts using stolen passwords and usernames from the dark web.

Quickly, they’re able to exploit that account for their own scams. Sometimes buying high value items with their victim’s stored payment details. Or posing as a legitimate seller to post fake listings. Authorities count this as a serious form of identity theft.

How to Spot a Scam | 5 Common Online Marketplace Scams

Refund claims fraud

Roughly 10% of all returned goods are based on fraudulent returns and the manipulation of return policies.

There are all kinds of refund fraud. For instance, defective returns. This is where someone purchases something they already own, to then return their old, defective item, instead of the new item they just purchased. Or “bricking” which is when someone strips electronics for valuable components, then returns the unusable item for money back. Scammers are also known to send counterfeit goods in their returns. Often, by the time sellers notice the misdemeanor, the scammer has disappeared without a trace.

In 2023, Amazon acknowledged that one particular refund fraud scam cost them $700,000. A crime ring recruited legitimate shoppers to purchase items, get a refund, but find cunning ways to keep the items or sell them for profit.

13 red flags to spot a scam on your online marketplace

  • Sellers offering expensive goods at too-good-to-be-true prices.
  • Sellers with multiple listings of the same products.
  • They sell a mix of expensive items (e.g. Apple Monitors) and cheap, lower-quality items (this flags an inconsistency).
  • Doctored images (although, this is becoming harder to detect with AI image generators).
  • The ‘payment link’ starts with ‘http’ not ‘https’ (‘https’ links are encrypted for user security).
  • Their IP address doesn’t match where they say they are.
  • They have an usually high percentage of reviews for how many items have been purchased from their store, and all of them are positive.
  • They have multiple negative reviews from verified buyers.
  • The same points or phrases keep coming up in their reviews (e.g. “well-made”, or “looks exactly like it does in the picture”).
  • There are suspicious changes on their account — changing a name or address that varies vastly from the original (this could be a sign of an account takeover).
  • There are multiple accounts paired with their IP address.
  • Buyers consistently return the items they’ve purchased.
  • They try to mimic other brands (e.g. Their username is very similar to well-known brands. They might call themselves something like ‘Dior Outlet Official’).

Online marketplace scams

How we can help you stop scams and protect your users

ID verification is just one part of the puzzle. Themis helps you build a picture of user behavior post-onboarding through continual monitoring.

Using AI, behavioural analytics and cluster technology, our scam detection solution flags suspicious activity, such as:

  • Bypass
  • Fake reviews
  • Poor customer feedback
  • Suspicious account behavior

From one dashboard, you can detect bad actors and emerging threats on your platform. Armed with this knowledge, your team can then take immediate action to mitigate the biggest risks and protect your users.

Get In Touch

Find out how we can  help protect your business against fraud. We’d love to hear from you.

Download this related publication

Blog Posts

SpotLight

Stay on top of the ever-changing financial crime landscape by accessing the latest information on emerging criminal techniques and the risks associated with carrying out business with particular industries or in particular jurisdictions.

What Businesses Need to Know

December 2025
UAE 2025 AML Reforms: What Businesses Need to Know

The UAE’s 2025 AML/CFT law marks a major regulatory shift, replacing the 2018 framework with stricter compliance, stronger enforcement and greater accountability. With expanded scope, dual oversight and higher penalties, businesses must strengthen AML controls ahead of the 2026 FATF evaluation.

The Evolving Landscape of Financial Crime

December 2025
When AI Breaks the Rules: The Evolving Landscape of Financial Crime

AI is transforming financial crime as much as compliance. The same tools used to detect risk are now automating fraud, laundering and cybercrime at scale. From AI-driven phishing to synthetic identities, our latest report explores how threats are evolving and how organisations can respond.

Behind the Scenes of Scam Call Centres

December 2025
FinCrime Times | Behind the Scenes of Scam Call Centres

Scam call centres now operate like tech startups, using outsourced labour, data-driven tactics and AI to scale fraud globally. Their professional structure makes them hard to shut down, driving huge financial losses and severe emotional harm to victims worldwide.

How Fraudsters Target Holiday Giving

December 2025
Exploiting Goodwill: How Fraudsters Target Holiday Giving

The holiday season drives generosity and year-end giving, but also a surge in charity fraud. In 2024, UK consumers lost over £1.2m to fake charity scams, while charities lose £1.65bn annually. This article explores how these scams work, warning signs, and how to protect yourself.

Uncertainty, Fraud and Knowledge Gaps

November 2025
FinCrime Times | Fraud in the Illegal Wildlife Trade

The illegal wildlife trade generates over US$48 billion annually, driving species extinction, biodiversity loss and ecosystem collapse. As global enforcement intensifies, tackling IWT remains a critical challenge for environmental and financial crime prevention.

Festive Deals Could Cost More Than You Think

November 2025
Steals or Scams? Festive Deals Could Cost More Than You Think

As UK spending surges for Black Friday and Christmas, online scams spike. Fraudsters use fake websites, counterfeit products and AI-enhanced tactics to steal money and personal data. Shoppers must stay vigilant.

Identity fraud and the blurred edges of the self

November 2025
FinCrime Times | Identity fraud and the blurred edges of the self

Identity fraud now extends far beyond data breaches and cloned credit cards. It includes scams that harvest personal information through fake job ads, fabricated profiles that meet onboarding checks, and AI-generated impersonation capable of fooling biometric security.

Key implications after the US lifts sanctions on Belavia

November 2025
Key implications after the US lifts sanctions on Belavia

US Department of the Treasury lifted OFAC sanctions on Belavia on 4 Nov, easing curbs on Belarus’s state airline. Amid EU bans and Boeing route restrictions, analysts warn of higher sanctions evasion and parallel imports risks via Russia. Explore impacts on compliance, due diligence and trade.

The Victims On The other Side Of The Bitcoin

November 2025
FinCrime Times | Pig Butchering Investment Scams

“Pig butchering” is a fast-growing cryptocurrency scam where fraudsters build trusted and sometimes romantic relationships to lure victims into fake investment schemes, ultimately stealing large sums of money.

The Changing Landscape of Drug Trafficking in the Gulf

October 2025
Navigating New Routes: The Changing Landscape of Drug Trafficking in the Gulf

This blog examines the evolving threat of the global illicit drug trade in the Persian Gulf, highlighting four key trends we’re closely monitoring.

Cobalt, Batteries and Electric Vehicles

October 2025
Cobalt, Batteries and Electric Vehicles: Untangling The Global Supply Chain

Cobalt powers modern technology and electric vehicles but is tied to exploitation, corruption, and environmental harm. This article unpacks global cobalt supply chains, from DRC mines to battery factories, and shows how Themis helps businesses identify and manage related ESG risks.

U.S. Commerce Department Unveils Game-Changing Export Control Rule

October 2025
U.S. Commerce Department Unveils Game-Changing Export Control Rule Targeting Affiliates

The U.S. has just tightened its grip on global trade: a new BIS “affiliates rule” now pulls thousands of companies worldwide under U.S. export controls. If ownership links are hidden, you could still be exposed—discover why this game-changing rule is reshaping compliance everywhere.

Essential Reads on Financial Crime

August 2025
Back to School Reading List: Essential Reads on Financial Crime

We’ve handpicked a selection of standout books our team discovered over the summer—perfect picks to kick off the “back-to-school" season. These compelling reads offer deep insight into financial crimes, the systemic vulnerabilities they exploit, and their far-reaching consequences.

The CFO's Guide to Smarter Investments in Financial Crime and Beyond

August 2025
The CFO’s Guide to Smarter Investments in Financial Crime and Beyond

AI is fast becoming a high-ROI tool in financial crime and compliance. From cutting costs and boosting efficiency to enhancing resilience, strategic AI investments are helping CFOs do more with less - transforming risk management and unlocking new value across the financial sector.

The UK's 2025 National Risk Assessment

July 2025
The UK’s 2025 National Risk Assessment on Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing

The UK’s latest National Risk Assessment (NRA) reveals how money laundering and terrorist financing are evolving—and how the UK is fighting back. A vital guide for AML policy, it arms businesses with intelligence to spot risks and stay protected.

Demands Deeper Due Diligence

July 2025
Beyond the Surface: Why OFAC’s 50 Percent Rule Demands Deeper Due Diligence

Many clients have heard of the OFAC 50 Percent Rule but aren’t sure how it affects them. It’s far-reaching, with hidden sanctions risks. This post explains the rule, why it demands deeper due diligence, and steps to identify and mitigate those risks.

UAE Steps Up the Heat on Dirty Money

June 2025
UAE Steps Up the Heat on Dirty Money

In June, the EU removed the UAE from its list of high-risk jurisdictions from an AML perspective, signaling growing international confidence in the country’s financial crime oversight.

Insurance Fraud Detection

March 2025
Insurance Fraud Detection

This article explains how data and analytics are used to detect insurance fraud more effectively.

Land Conversion and Financial Crime

February 2025
Risk Assessment Updates

New updates to the Land Conversion and Financial Crime Risk Assessment link environmental harm to financial crime. Cattle rustling in Nigeria and Cameroon is now red-rated, with added risks on carbon credit fraud, child labour, mining corruption, and gold smuggling.

What is Human Trafficking?

October 2024
What is Human Trafficking?

An overview of modern slavery, distinguishing between human trafficking, smuggling, and forced labor. It highlights the global prevalence of exploitation and the importance of understanding these definitions to combat such crimes.

Ensuring Financial Transparency in Dubai Real Estate

August 2024
Ensuring Financial Transparency in Dubai Real Estate

Dubai’s $160B foreign-owned real estate market faces money laundering risks. The UAE now requires reporting of property deals over AED 55K via REAR. Criminals like Daniel Kinahan have exploited property to hide illicit funds, underscoring the need for strict compliance.

Human Trafficking and the Digital World

August 2024
Human Trafficking & the Digital World

Examines how digital platforms and cryptocurrencies facilitate human trafficking, allowing traffickers to operate anonymously and at scale, posing challenges for law enforcement.

Nexus of Sanctions and Trade-Based Financial Crime in Hong Kong

August 2024
Exploring the Nexus of Sanctions and Trade-Based Financial Crime in Hong Kong

Investigates how sanctions intersect with trade-based financial crimes in Hong Kong, highlighting the complexities businesses face in navigating regulatory compliance.

The Hidden Harm of Financial Crimes on Mental Health

May 2024
The Hidden Harm of Financial Crimes on Mental Health

Financial crimes cause more than economic harm—they hit mental health too. UK data shows 60% of fraud victims face distress; Ghana research links corruption to anxiety and depression. This blog calls for tackling both psychological and financial impacts.

The Disproportionate Impact of Environmental Crime on Women

March 2024
International Women's Day 2024

Environmental crime worsens gender inequality, driving violence, trafficking, and hardship for women—especially in regions like the DRC and Peru. Women defenders face abuse, and climate change deepens risks like water scarcity, child marriage, and health threats. Tackling these crimes is key to protecting women’s rights and safety.

Unleashing AI's Potential for Good in Financial Crime Prevention

February 2024
Unleashing AI's Potential for Good in Financial Crime Prevention

AI is transforming financial crime prevention—improving detection, reducing costs, and streamlining compliance. Generative AI and graph networks boost due diligence, while ethical, human-guided use counters criminal misuse. Themis champions tech-human collaboration.

How Fuzzy Is Your Logic?

August 2023
How Fuzzy Is Your Logic?

Explores the application of fuzzy logic in Anti-Money Laundering (AML) systems, emphasising its role in improving name-matching accuracy and reducing false positives, thereby enhancing compliance efficiency.

Tree Thieves

July 2023
Book Review : 'Tree Thieves: Crime and Survival in the Woods' by Lyndsie Bourgon

This book focusses on the challenges faced by law enforcement in North West USA and in British Columbia to combat illegal logging, as well as those of the timber-industry communities established since the late 19th century to maintain meaningful and financially viable lives.

Efforts to Stamp Out Financial Crime

July 2023
Progress Applauded in the UAE's Efforts to Stamp Out Financial Crime

The FATF has highlighted the UAE’s progress in fighting financial crime. Its third enhanced follow-up report upgraded three recommendation ratings for the country, marking a step forward in meeting international standards.

Unravelling the Crisis and FATF's Response?

July 2023
Lebanon's Economic Woes

Lebanon’s economic collapse, fuelled by debt, corruption, and instability, has led to hyperinflation and greater financial crime risk. In Oct 2024, the FATF grey-listed Lebanon. The country pledges a two-year reform plan to boost transparency and restore investor confidence.

A Guide to the Legality of Foreign Cannabis Proceeds in the UK

June 2023
A Guide to the Legality of Foreign Cannabis Proceeds in the UK

The UK treats profits from legal overseas cannabis businesses as criminal property under the Proceeds of Crime Act. Few cases qualify for exceptions, creating a legal grey area—so anyone handling such funds should proceed cautiously and seek legal advice.

Fighting Dirty Money in the UK

April 2023
The Economic Crime Plan 2023-26

The UK’s 2023–2026 Economic Crime Plan commits £400M to tackle money laundering, kleptocracy, and fraud, with reforms to Companies House, crypto, and sanctions. Progress is clear, but critics urge more urgency and funding. Success depends on public-private collaboration.

An Exception To Tattle Tailing

March 2023
An Exception to Tattle Tailing

Suspicious Activity Reports (SARs) are key to fighting financial crime, with 42% of fraud found via tip-offs. Rising UK SARs and account freezes show their impact. Themis urges strong reporting systems and whistleblower protections to foster transparency.

The Murky World of Family, Offshore Companies, and 19th Century London Taverns

March 2023
The Murky World of Family, Offshore Companies, and 19th Century London Taverns

Corrupt elites still exploit the UK property market via offshore structures and relatives to hide assets. Over 18,000 firms remain non-compliant. With cases of children holding luxury homes, Themis calls for tougher enforcement as new UK and FATF guidance target transparency gaps.

Do Countries With Higher Corruption Levels Perform Worse on DEI?

March 2023
Do Countries With Higher Corruption Levels Perform Worse on DEI?

Corruption undermines sustainable development, financial integrity, and DEI. A Themis–Denominator study links lower corruption to higher DEI scores. Marginalised groups, especially women, suffer most. Promoting diversity and transparency is key to fairer societies.

A Reckoning

March 2023
The Reckoning of the Adani Group

Hindenburg Research accuses India’s Adani Group of fraud, alleging stock manipulation, shell firms, and nepotism—halving Gautam Adani’s net worth and shaking investor confidence. The case highlights how financial crime can roil markets and the need for strong due diligence.

The EU's Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive

March 2023
The EU's Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive

Supply chain failures have linked firms like Inditex and Skechers to forced labour and reputational risk. The EU’s CSDDD will require large companies to address human rights and environmental harms. Themis offers tools to assess suppliers and fight modern slavery.

Where are we in the Fight Against Wildlife Trafficking?

March 2023
World Wildlife Day

On World Wildlife Day and CITES’ 50th year, Themis reflects on tackling illegal wildlife trade—the 4th largest financial crime. Laws, AI, forensics, and global cooperation drive change, but shifting demand, like ivory to hippo teeth, shows challenges remain.

Make Sure to Vet Your Dog Breeder

February 2023
Make Sure to Vet Your Dog Breeder

Puppy smuggling in the UK has surged post-pandemic, with organised crime exploiting demand and loopholes to import sick or underage dogs. Despite new laws, enforcement gaps remain. Themis urges buyer vigilance—tools like Themis Search can help spot breeder risks

The Dark Side of Valentine's Day

February 2023
The Dark Side of Valentine's Day

Romance scams rose 30% in 2022, with victims losing £8,234 on average—especially men and those aged 65–74. Scammers use fake profiles and emotional manipulation. Themis urges due diligence in dating; tools like Themis Search can flag risks and help platforms protect users.

Financial Crime in the Russia-Ukraine Crisis

May 2022
Digital Currencies and Financial Crime in the Russia-Ukraine Crisis

Crypto plays roles in both social good and crime—over $50M has aided Ukraine, but bad actors use it to evade sanctions and launder funds, notably via the UAE and Central African Republic. Themis calls for stronger due diligence and compliance to curb misuse.

A Catalyst for Human Trafficking Emerging Risks Facing Ukrainian Refugees

March 2022
A Catalyst for Human Trafficking Emerging Risks Facing Ukrainian Refugees

The Russian invasion of Ukraine has heightened trafficking risks for women and children. Over 2.5M flee, with traffickers exploiting chaos, especially in Moldova, Poland, and Italy. The OSCE urges swift action to warn refugees of false offers and protect them.